Community drum circles were inspired by the introduction of African drumming to the United States, and are an American modification/adaptation of elements of African cultures. They are different than authentic traditional African music/dance ensembles, in which there are highly developed traditions, including specific rhythms, instruments, songs, dances, etc.
Arthur Hull has done more than anyone to develop what he calls "facilitated community drum circles." One of his most important sources of inspiration, and an important mentor, was Babatunde Olatunji.
As I mailed you this past weekend, on Wednesday we will discuss two readings.
- An informal, conversational-style interview with Arthur Hull and Babatunde Olatunji.
- Eric Charry's very academic introduction to Baba's memoir.
The interview can be printed out. The introduction can't. So especially for the introduction, you need to write notes. Write down specific quotes (with the page number) so that you can refer to them in the discussion. Also bring your laptop or tablet computer so you can follow along as others make comments.
You can also listen to the Drums of Passion album at audio.depauw.edu. Sign in using your network/eservices/Moodle username and password and you'll see the album listed for this course. It's also available on iTunes and probably on Spotify, etc.
This video in which Carlos Santana talks about the way Olatunji influenced him includes some excellent video (starting at 3:15).
In the comment section below, write about what you find most striking about Olatunji's story and sense of mission. Then also identify at least one of the contradictions/paradoxes that Charry discusses as he works to present Olatunji's life and work in historical and cultural context.
And tell us how you respond to the music.
Olatunji certainly sounds like a powerfully inspiring person. I appreciate how committed he is to his cause, not only spreading the joy of rhythm but also the sense of unity and compassion that comes with it. One of his comments struck me in particular: "We are trying to put together the great things of the past with the present for the future." I feel that is the greatest struggle for musicians today, and it's part of what the 21CM program aims to do. We must remember our classical roots and innovate our craft in a way that appeals to the present in order to better the future. It is important to keep the past alive because integrating the past and present shapes a brighter, culturally lively future.
ReplyDeleteI am amazed that people in the 1950s and 60s were so interested in African culture and drumming, yet shamed the very performers who helped bring the music to the American public. For example, DuVall explains how the women would hide the fact that they were Afro-Cuban drummers from their employers, and when they were discovered, they would be fired. That makes absolutely no sense to me.
I really enjoy Drums of Passion, but it's not something I would listen to regularly. I love how it really makes you feel the beat in your heart. I feel more energized when I listen to it.
Something interested I noticed was that Olatunji was able to have such a widespread effect in bringing African culture in general to the US because he wasn’t born into the drumming lineage. Without therefore being bound by “any one tradition” (pg. 17) he was able shape something universally recognizable and label-able as ‘African.’ It was such an approach, one that focused more on a simple philosophy of peace and love, and with a general focus on the spiritual rather than the religious, that allowed Olatunji to have the kind of widespread success he did.
ReplyDeleteI believe this is a similar approach that classical musicians should consider in today’s century. With how interconnected the world has become, and with how many musicians there are out there, it’s easy to lose the ability to transmit a piece the way it was intended, contextually. I mean this in the sense that, say, a dance by Bach holds and transmits a different cultural essence—one of the era it was composed for—than what we may view it for today. Therefore there has to be a balance between giving people today something they can connect with while simultaneously showing them where its roots lie.
I believe this something that Olatunji considered when spreading African culture through his drumming. Paradoxically, this may have caused his message to become too broad and all-encompassing for people looking to transmit a very accurate and authentic sense of African cultures, it was its openness that allowed for a common person to be drawn in. Perhaps he could’ve benefitted from having put slightly more specific concepts of African culture into his drumming circles.
Having listened to some songs off of the album I can see how it would’ve jarred and attracted listeners. It has a certain primal quality and intensity to it that I doubt any other music on the market would’ve had. That said, I don’t personally think I could listen to the whole thing attentively as it is not my style of music. It’s certainly interesting though to get a glimpse at another culture’s musicality.
As Erin already mentioned before, Olatunji does sound like a very powerful and inspiring person. It's not hard to pick up on how much of an impact he had on Mickey Hart. The way he is described by Hart shows how much he cared about blending everything together to make a new, innovative sound. "He put in a little bit of this and a little bit of that, and he made the stew just irrisistable."-Hart. I really like how his goal was to unify and spread compassion through his music. I also agree with Erin that as musicians in the present time, we need to find a way to keep people interested in classical music.
ReplyDeleteI also agree with Erin that it was very odd that people could be so interested in a culture, yet disrespect the people who brought their music to the American public. If I was interested in a culture and wanted to know more, I wouldn't push people away that tried to help me understand their music. As a woman, I also like DuVall's example of how women would hide that they were Afro-Cuban drummers in fear of being fired from their jobs. I just can't make a connection as to how an employer would fire someone over what they did in their spare time that didn't interfere with their work performance. It's ridiculous.
Drums of Passion is a really unique sound, but not something I would turn on in my car as I drive to somewhere like Wal-Mart. I do really enjoy the sound, though. I could see myself turning this on while I clean my room so I can dance around and act goofy. I feel very energized while I listen to it.
I personally enjoyed reading and analyzing Olatunji's background and his overall impact on American society. Although it is apparent that he is a natural leader and an excellent musician, Olatunji understands the true purpose of being a drum community facilitator and builds his philosophy of the world on this responsibility. For example, Olatunji mentions that he tries to practice what he preaches, especially on the issues of "getting even". He believes that he only has an obligation to people that treat his with respect and does not waste time and energy on those who treat him poorly. Initially, I had a difficult time relating this philosophy to his involvement in the drum community, but this is the general attitude that he must have as a facilitator. He must communicate love and passion when leading this type of a community. However, I found Olatunji idea of culture very interesting since many Americans today do not have an equal understanding on what it means to preserve culture. For example, an interview with Raven Symone on the Oprah Winfrey Network received popularity last year because of the question of whether blacks should be considered "African American" or just "American". Raven Symone did mention in this interview that she cannot trace her roots this far back, but the argument that she made contrasts with Olatunji's desire to preserve African culture. I do not have my own opinion on this, but it is interesting to compare Olatunji's philosophies with modern issues such as this.
ReplyDeleteI was aware of the Civil Rights Movement and the events that led to it, but I never understood Olatunji's impact on American culture at that time. I find it interesting that African drumming was so closely associated with African dances and did not find its independence until much later. It is also interesting that the independence of African drumming was "a uniquely American development, with little African precedent". This is an example of how successful Olatunji was in integrating African culture into American society.
I enjoyed listening to Drums of Passion. It provides a sense of energy and pulse that affects emotions in a somewhat positive way.
While I see where Rachel is coming from with her comment discussing "getting even," I think the real message might be a little different. Olatunji brings up getting even in a more positive manner. He describes that getting even is truly beneficial if it means repaying someone that has done treated you with respect and kindness. It is in this way that he tries to practice what he preaches, by facilitating drum groups to repay the happiness and kindness.
ReplyDeleteThe most interesting part for me, however, was how Olatunji was able to recognize such a huge problem and address in the most productive way possible. When "Drums of Passion" came out, it was not only at the right time in history (with many African nations becoming independent and fighting for civil rights), but with the right knowledge and in the right place. Olatunji approached the presentation of African tradition in a way that Americans could understand by doing things such as putting his music in the LP format and speaking about its meaning in terms of spirits. While the African drumming may stand for much more than just the presence of spirits, it gave the people of America a feeling of inclusiveness in a tradition that was completely foreign to them. He also knew that recording with the most popular record company at the time, Columbia, would legitimize his efforts.
Even with this effort, Charry points out that many Americans began to associate the healing power of drum circles to be part of a global utopia instead of the African culture. The philosophy behind drum circles says that "anyone can do it." Saying this, though, separates the connection of African culture from a drum circle. By saying anyone can do it, it's as if the feelings that result from participating in a drum circle come from a magical "consciousness" that is universal. The barrier between true African rhythm (performed by talented individuals) and a simple drum circle must be overcome if African culture is to be fully represented.
The music, to me, is a form of meditation. While the initial rhythms may be complex, their repetitive nature makes them simple. It is because of this that they provide a sort of meditative energy that no other genre can replicate.
His story interested me a lot because it was not music that actually brought him to the United States. Dreaming to work for his nation, he was intended to study administration. However, due to a lack of money, he could not keep going to the school and music saved his life in the US. After he started his career as a musician, he still appreciated and cherished his community that kept expanding thanks to his music. I was also amazed at the fact that he was encouraged to tell his culture to his friends in the US and eventually created a huge impact on American culture when the civil right movements were occurring. His love for his native culture and environment moved people's heart and he could express his feelings through his own music, which I think is crucial when offering music to public.
ReplyDeleteSince I am not very familiar with African culture and this is my first time to learn about him or drum circle itself, I only have a very shallow understanding in this type of music.However, I could feel something very passionate and indescribable things in the sound.
What I found interesting about this interview is the fact that many famous singers and groups tried to interpret some form of African music at one point. Or at one point listened and looked to Olatunji's music for inspiration. Such as Coltrane who wrote a song called Tunji for Olatunji. Santana talks of how there was a deeper meaning to all of his music. It wasn't merely banging on drums, they all told a story. Most of it having to do with nature. When listening to the music you can actually here the rumbling of thunder or the river flowing. Now that i'm listening for a story I'm beginning to hear one. Along with this I love he acknowledges the fact that a lot of this was hippie stuff but it wasn't people sitting in a circle and getting high. There was a spiritual connection that the whole circle felt and and together they would create a rhythm that would connect everyone to eachother. In the interview they call it "rhythm fumes" and how he would become one with the rhythm.
ReplyDeleteI think everyone needs to experience this type of energy at one point in their life. The connection is so deep and they get so into it, it's almost a refreshing experience and you come out it feeling relaxed and at peace. I know I've entered this class a few times feeling stressed and uneasy, but then when the class is over I feel like a new me. African culture and music because I feel like it's something the live off of. It's not simply making music for the sake of making music. It's something they believe in and worship and feel a connection to.
The resources we have been set to explore over these past couple of days have revealed a rich history surrounding Olatunji's story and the immense impact his work has had on US culture. From the newly established Nigeria to the racially charged United States, Olatunji set out on his life adventure hoping to become a UN ambassador, but arriving instead at a position of musical diplomacy. This is perhaps the most interesting aspect of his life, the way in which he became not a political persuader, but a human activist, influencing those around him, and the world around him, through his music. He found a way to tap into that primal instinct, the global Utopian ideals that the US is so fond of perpetuating, at a period of the perfect storm for the issue of race, catalyzing the incorporation of African heritage, pride, and culture into the American identity, one in which that demographic had been suppressed.
ReplyDeleteAnother aspect of the dialogue that I found especially engaging was the reaction of African traditionalists and those who felt that Olatunji's work was belittling the true African drumming experience or diminishing the art. The idea of cultural appropriation with regards to this topic is also quite prominent, with this Black tradition being consumed and transformed by the White majority. Whether this is a negative instance of one group stripping another of their heritage or a positive example of a shared connection between differing cultures I am not entirely sure, but the question is nonetheless important to the discussion.
I find it most interesting that Olatunji was basically a civil rights activist in his own right. His timing in arrival to United States could not have been any more poignant for his overall goals. Even from his original goal as a diplomat. The fact that he brought his knowledge and experience of African culture to both the white and black students of his college is quite inspiring especially considering the recent events on our campus and its new focus on inclusiveness. He started his career trying to spread his form of music on college campuses because usually the students of our age are generally more open-minded or at least susceptible to hearing a new message and understanding it. In particular music tends to have a huge effect of people our age. Olatunji was very smart to start his message on college campuses across the country. All in all I find that music has a special power over people that many other outlets do not and that the music or rhythm can embody an idea to present to the public. Music makes us vulnerable to new ideas, customs, and cultures as a whole that we never may have experienced in our lifetime.
ReplyDeleteWhat I found to be most interesting about Olatunji's story is his idea of earth and man. Olatunji believed that drumming was simply putting a person back in touch with his roots. He said that we are a people who began with "body percussion," meaning that rhythm/ drumming has been a part of culture since the beginning of life. Because we are all part of earth, we are all able to unite through drumming. I thought it to be a very humane act on Olatunji's behalf to want to lead people (first African Americans) back to their roots and not despise them for their ignorance. With this, I found Charry's words about "specialized training" to contradict Olatunji's beliefs. Olatunji's belief is that everyone is from earth and therefore already has the rhythm in his body. So, no specialized training should be required for a person to participate in drumming. Even Olatunji himself was not a drummer at first.
ReplyDeleteAfter listening to the Drum of Passion album, I was able to reminisce on my life as a dancer. I began dancing at the age of seven and learned ballet, jazz, and African dance. In Charry's introduction, he referred to Katherine Dunham as being an influential figure in American culture. Some of my dance instructors were students of the late Katherine Dunham, so I grew up dancing to Olatunji's music. When I listened to the album, I danced along in my head and frequently moved my body to the music. African music, such as Olatunji's, has always been a part of my life and has helped me to express myself.
I find it very interesting that Olatunji stressed that drum circles and African drumming should stay in schools throughout the US, in the same way that there is physical education and art education. This way, African drumming can become more than just a fad, it can become a part of our culture. As many others have talked about, it is incredibly rewarding that there is no sort of specialized training required to succeed in a drum circle setting, and it is a way to really connect with both yourself and others. Olatunji, and the drummers in Drums of Passion were not the most renowned African drummers in the world, but the album was "an extraordinary document made by extraordinary people at an extraordinary time". It did not matter if the musicians were the best drummers, they were still playing their part and educating the public. I find Olatunji's work so powerful because he was so focused on the education aspect of music, which is important to me as a music educator.
ReplyDeleteThe idea behind Drums of Passion and even regular drum circles is about simplicity and returning to roots. It is so easy to get caught up in the technicalities of music, and Olatunji has helped many to just let go and just listen and feel. Olatunji's job in many aspects was an educator. Whether he was intentionally, or unintentionally educating, he was teaching people to be more accepting of a wide range of ideas. I have always been fascinated by music that was rooted in european tradition, and I really enjoyed listening to Drums of Passion, and I found all of the musical ideas fascinating.
Olatunji was obviously a "man on a mission," as Arthur Hull puts it. Even before he got off the boat to America, he was already moving and shaking with his hand drum. And what better way is there to peacefully further something such as the Civil Rights movement than through music? Olatunji fearlessly began to empower African Americans by educating them about their roots and simultaneously introduced African music into American culture with his album "Drums of Passion." I find him to be both an inspirational musician, person, activist, and educator.
ReplyDeleteA contradictory point touched on by a couple of other people was that universal rhythmic expression is sometimes seen as too all-encompassing for those of African descent "seeking historical connections with their past." However, I feel that for the majority of people, drum circles still have a healing, community-inspiring aspect to them that is quite accessible.
As Spencer mentioned, Drums of Passion is full of complex, yet repetitive rhythms. The rhythms and instruments are layered and as each one enters, I became more invested in the groove. I've never actively listened to something like Drums of Passion, but it was truly enthralling and enjoyable. The listening experience was almost like an energizing form of meditation.
Olatunji was a huge advocate and figurehead of the Civil Rights movement almost because he was at the right place at the right time. He also inspired a large amount of the black arts movement in the 70's with his success. In a time where African music was often misunderstood by the dominant culture, he helped legitimize and popularize it. Even after the Success of Drums of Passion in 1959 he continued teaching intimate workshops and educating on the positive spiritual and mental effects of communal drumming.
ReplyDeleteI find it kind of funny that while he stressed commune with nature to promote a healing process, that the corporations picked up and commercialized his ideas. Companies like Remo created synthetic drums that sort of removed the need for expensive handmade drums, that Olatunji advocated for. However, this helped make his dream to put a drum in every household more accessible. While we don't know his inner turmoil on the matter, he eventually advocated for Remo. It seems that at a certain point his legacy and influence became bigger than his control over it. I can imagine seeing a bunch of people in suits and ties in an office place playing drums as a team building exercise. Just a little later in the article it goes on to discuss the difficulty of certain african drumming rhythms. While it could have felt inaccessible to most, he emphasized inclusiveness in this previously more esoteric art.
I was surprised at Olatunji's enthusiasm for drum circles and his optimism towards what they can accomplish.
ReplyDelete"We are trying to put together the great things of the past with the present for the future. You know the sky is not the limit anymore, it is space now. We are discovering that we need to come back down to earth, from where we started. It’s as if we are trying to balance things up, in essence."
I personally don't agree with this sheer power of drum circles (if they do have as much power as he claims, wouldn't they be more widespread?)
I do agree that drum circles in communities can help grow already healthy communities into a flourishing community, but I don't think that it can amend problematic areas.
I felt that Olatunji contradicts himself when he discussed the culture of hand drumming. He talks about how there is an authentic hand drumming, but then claims that everyone has something to offer, regardless of their knowledge and skill.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteMany of us may call out Olatunji's "contradictions" as part of the lost hippie movement--in the video Santana even called himself a "hippie"--perhaps we really don't have the necessary context to totally understand. As a nation, the United States went through a spiritual awakening from the early 1950's through the early 1970's, moving away from a completely blind consumer culture to a more worldly-educated one. The peaceful protests of the Civil Rights and anti-war movements and "loving your brother" were newer concepts. Cultural revolution was very really. With a more conscious mindset of the social climate around the time of Drums of Passion, I think we can understand Olatunji's meaning behind "everyone has something to offer" comment, as Thomas Ring put it. While there are the tradition rhythms of West Africa that must be preserved, Olatunji--with his village leader training--was trying to bring a community together. With assistance of many others in a time of awakening, he succeeded.
ReplyDeleteOlatunji was directly a musician and ambassador of African culture, but indirectly he was a facilitator for social change, similar to a facilitator for a drum circle. He didn't carry the loudest voice, but he did initially bring musicians together and provide them with an influence that otherwise, may never have happened. American popular music largely come from Africa, but Olatunji's debut album opened up a connection to roots music of Africa, and newer African music. Would Hugh Masekela, Fela Kuti and others ever have half the popularity they did if Olatunji's album didn't exist? It's sometimes difficult to debate what would and would not have happened, but it's extremely valuable to have a recent musical occurrence that we can find the epicenter of: the popularity of African music and Drums of Passion. (Note: because Drums of Passion is an album title, it should be italicized or underlined, not in quotation marks.)
Olatunji's music was instrumental in the idea of "world music". He was a part of this "hippie movement" and as Santana puts it, he too was a part of it. I appreciated the fact that he continued the African culture into the American culture. I believe that this idea of cultural identity plays a huge role in his own music. Many African Americans did not know the music of their own culture and I believe that as a society it was necessary for Olatunji to broaden their perspective and show them or rather play with the music of their culture.
ReplyDelete