In honor of Black History month, I have decided to upload an acapella version of the spiritual "Swing Low, Sweet Chariot." If you attended the King's Singers' concert, you heard their version of this spiritual. This is one of my all time favorite negro spirituals.
I personally did not enjoy the King's Singers' version of "Swing Low,..." I felt that it lacked the spirit and emotion of spirituals. This is a positive song because it saying that no matter what your problems are here on earth, you will one day be safe and free of worries in heaven with the Lord. This spiritual should be sung with a spirit of excitement and longing even if it is sung at a slow tempo.
What are your thoughts on this spiritual? If you attended the King's Singers' concert, what were your thoughts on their version?
Ahh very interesting point of view Angel! I appreciate it :) However, I have to disagree with you. I felt as though the King Singer's brought a different kind of spiritual energy to the song. It was a different take and I appreciated the originality.
ReplyDeleteOut of all the Kings Singers Concert, I found the spiritual portion the most engaging. However I agree with Angel, in that I think they could have brought a lot more raw emotion to the performance in every aspect. Maybe it would have taken a little bit away from the technical perfection, but in the end it would have meant more. I loved the arrangement and the way they sung the song, I just think it was missing the raw spirit that is so evident in all spiritual music.
ReplyDeleteFirst off, holy s*** can that bass singer go low. That was amazing.
ReplyDeleteI feel like this version has more emotion that the King's Singers' version. My biggest issue with their performance was that they got too caught up in the technical aspect of the music. I felt like they approached the songs with questions like "how many harmonies can we do? how many key changes can we make? how high and low can we go?" rather than "how can we transmit the message of the music best?".
That said, I didn't particularly like this version either. It was definitely more engaging, but once it sped up and got super-jubilant the lyrics' meaning felt kind of lost to me and I would've preferred some more interesting harmonies/melodies.
Hi Angel! While I enjoyed the King's Singers concert overall, I didn't really enjoy the first half. I do agree that many of the spirituals weren't performed with much "spirit." I recall "Swing Low" being one of the most somber sounding arrangements of the entire program; it actually made me feel sad. I had a similar reaction to the encore of "At Last." Being a blues fan myself--yes, that Etta James album is blues, it was released on the Chess label for goodness sake--I knew the tune and was excited to hear it. The arrangement, I felt was lacking. While Etta James was never the sweat-drenched blues of Howlin' Wolf, for example, the King's Singers never provided the soul power that James did on her 1961 album. Would the King's Singers be better suited for the folk repertoire of their homeland?
ReplyDeleteSadly, I wasn't able to attend the King's Singers Friday night. However I have heard multiple recordings of their version and I have to say they lack some emotion behind their singing. It seems very structured and it's absolutely gorgeous, but live they lacked emotion to me for some reason. This version that you showed us though is very up-lifting and I love it. But, when it speeds up I start to lose interest in it and it gets to be too much for me.
ReplyDelete